Sesi Belajar Budaya KerjaWorkplace Culture Session

Crab Mentality di Tempat Kerjaat Work

Definisi, penyebab, dan dampaknya, dirangkum dari riset peer-reviewed, termasuk studi terbaru pada karyawan di Kota Bandung. Definition, causes, and consequences, distilled from peer-reviewed research, including a recent study of employees in Bandung City.

Rangga Irawan PrasetyoDigital HR ArchitectDigital HR Architect

ranggairawan.comMateri & referensiMaterials & references

01 / 11

Janji Sesi IniThe Promise

Di akhir sesi ini, Anda akan mampuBy the end of this session, you will be able to

1

Mengenali crab mentalityRecognize crab mentality

dan membedakannya dari kompetisi sehat, dua hal yang sering tertukar di tempat kerja.and distinguish it from healthy competition, two things often confused at work.

2

Menjelaskan akar penyebabnyaExplain its root causes

melalui empat lensa teori: social comparison, workplace envy, relative deprivation, dan self-esteem.through four theoretical lenses: social comparison, workplace envy, relative deprivation, and self-esteem.

3

Merancang respons tiga levelDesign a three-level response

di level individu, tim & kepemimpinan, dan organisasi, bukan sekadar menyalahkan orang per orang.at the individual, team & leadership, and organizational levels, not just blaming individuals.

Basis bukti: seluruh materi dirujuk dari jurnal peer-reviewed, antara lain Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior (2021), Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies (2019), Frontiers in Psychology (2022), dan studi karyawan Kota Bandung (2025). Evidence base: all material draws on peer-reviewed journals, including the Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior (2021), Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies (2019), Frontiers in Psychology (2022), and a 2025 study of employees in Bandung City.

02 / 11

DefinisiDefinition

Bukan kompetisi. Ini hal lain.Not competition. Something else.

Crab mentality adalah perilaku menjatuhkan, meremehkan, atau menghambat orang lain yang sedang maju, yang muncul saat keberhasilan orang lain dianggap sebagai ancaman. Crab mentality is the behavior of pulling down, belittling, or blocking others who are moving ahead, triggered when someone else's success is perceived as a threat.

Kompetisi sehatHealthy competition

Fokus menaikkan diri sendiri
Focused on raising yourself
Keberhasilan orang lain jadi standar belajar
Others' success becomes a learning benchmark
Energi dipakai untuk memanjat
Energy is spent climbing

Crab mentalityCrab mentality

Fokus menahan orang lain
Focused on holding others back
Keberhasilan orang lain dianggap ancaman
Others' success is treated as a threat
Energi dipakai untuk menarik turun
Energy is spent pulling down

Miller (2019); Uzum et al. (2022)

03 / 11

Asal IstilahOrigin of the Term

Ember berisi kepitingA bucket of crabs

Satu kepiting yang hampir keluar dari ember seolah ditarik kembali oleh kepiting lain. Tidak ada yang perlu memasang tutup: ember "menjaga dirinya sendiri". A crab nearly escaping the bucket appears to be pulled back by the others. No lid is needed: the bucket "guards itself".

Catatan penting: ini lebih tepat dipahami sebagai metafora sosial untuk perilaku manusia, bukan fakta biologis yang selalu benar tentang kepiting. Important note: this is best understood as a social metaphor for human behavior, not a universally accurate biological fact about crabs.

Uzum et al. (2022)

04 / 11

Dasar TeoriTheoretical Foundations

Empat lensa untuk membacanyaFour lenses to read it

Social comparison theory

Manusia menilai dirinya dengan membandingkan diri terhadap orang lain (Festinger).People evaluate themselves by comparing against others (Festinger).

Workplace envy

Iri di tempat kerja dapat bertransmutasi menjadi perilaku merugikan, termasuk social undermining (Duffy et al., 2021).Workplace envy can transmute into harmful behavior, including social undermining (Duffy et al., 2021).

Relative deprivation

Rasa dirugikan muncul bukan dari kondisi absolut, tetapi dari melihat orang lain lebih berhasil.A sense of loss arises not from absolute conditions, but from seeing others succeed more.

Self-esteem

Harga diri yang rapuh berkaitan dengan respons negatif terhadap keberhasilan orang lain (Uzum et al., 2022).Fragile self-esteem is linked to negative responses toward others' success (Uzum et al., 2022).

05 / 11

Temuan RisetResearch Findings

Tiga faktor, bukan satu kambing hitamThree factors, not one scapegoat

Studi 2025 pada karyawan di Kota Bandung menemukan crab mentality dibentuk oleh tiga lapis faktor sekaligus. A 2025 study of employees in Bandung City found crab mentality is shaped by three layers of factors at once.

IndividualRasa tidak aman, iri, harga diri rapuh, kecenderungan membandingkan diri.Insecurity, envy, fragile self-esteem, a tendency toward constant comparison.
SocietalNorma sosial dan cara lingkungan memaknai keberhasilan orang lain.Social norms and how the environment interprets other people's success.
OrganizationalGaya kepemimpinan, budaya perusahaan, tekanan kerja, dan dinamika internal.Leadership style, company culture, work pressure, and internal dynamics.

BANDUNG 2025 Purwaningwulan & Khaira (2025); temuan organisasi sejalan dengan Miller (2019).Purwaningwulan & Khaira (2025); organizational findings align with Miller (2019).

06 / 11

Wujud di Tempat KerjaHow It Shows Up at Work

Tiga perilaku yang paling sering munculThe three most common behaviors

Menahan informasiWithholding information

Akses, konteks, atau data sengaja tidak dibagikan agar rekan kerja gagal atau terlihat tidak kompeten.Access, context, or data is deliberately withheld so a colleague fails or looks incompetent.

Meremehkan ideDismissing ideas

Gagasan orang lain dikecilkan bukan karena kualitasnya, tetapi karena siapa yang mengusulkannya.Others' ideas are belittled not for their quality, but because of who proposed them.

Menghambat promosiBlocking promotion

Orang yang dianggap "terlalu cepat naik" dihalangi lewat gosip, penilaian bias, atau politik internal.People seen as "rising too fast" are held back through gossip, biased assessment, or internal politics.

Perilaku ini paling kuat muncul di lingkungan kerja yang sangat kompetitif dan politis (Miller, 2019).These behaviors are strongest in highly competitive, political work environments (Miller, 2019).

07 / 11

Dampak OrganisasiOrganizational Impact

Efek dominonya bisa diprediksiThe domino effect is predictable

Ujungnya bukan hanya angka kinerja: kesehatan psikologis kerja ikut tergerus. Karena itu, crab mentality perlu diperlakukan sebagai isu budaya kerja, bukan sekadar konflik personal. The end point is not just performance numbers: psychological wellbeing at work erodes too. That is why crab mentality must be treated as a workplace culture issue, not merely a personal conflict.

Miller (2019); Purwaningwulan & Khaira (2025)

08 / 11

ResponsResponse

Solusi tiga level, sesuai janji di awalA three-level response, as promised

Level 1 · IndividuLevel 1 · Individual

Kelola perbandinganManage comparison

Sadari pemicu social comparison pada diri sendiri
Notice your own social comparison triggers
Ubah iri menjadi benign envy: belajar dari yang berhasil
Turn envy into benign envy: learn from those who succeed
Bangun self-esteem lewat kemajuan diri yang terukur
Build self-esteem through measurable personal progress

Level 2 · Tim & KepemimpinanLevel 2 · Team & Leadership

Ubah normanyaReset the norms

Jadikan berbagi informasi sebagai norma, bukan kebaikan hati
Make information sharing a norm, not a favor
Beri pengakuan yang adil dan transparan
Give fair, transparent recognition
Rayakan keberhasilan rekan secara publik
Celebrate colleagues' wins publicly

Level 3 · OrganisasiLevel 3 · Organization

Perbaiki sistemnyaFix the system

Sistem promosi yang transparan dan berbasis kriteria
Transparent, criteria-based promotion systems
Ukur dan hargai kontribusi tim, bukan hanya individu
Measure and reward team contribution, not only individuals
Kurangi zero-sum design dalam insentif dan penilaian
Reduce zero-sum design in incentives and appraisal

Konsisten dengan tiga faktor temuan riset: individual, societal, organizational.Consistent with the three research factors: individual, societal, organizational.

09 / 11

Kontribusi Sesi IniContributions

Yang sudah kita bangun hari iniWhat we built today

Mendefinisikan crab mentality dan memisahkannya dari kompetisi sehat: bedanya ada di arah energi, memanjat atau menarik turun.Defined crab mentality and separated it from healthy competition: the difference lies in where the energy goes, climbing or pulling down.

Membedah empat akar teorinya: social comparison, workplace envy, relative deprivation, dan self-esteem, plus tiga faktor temuan riset Bandung 2025.Unpacked its four theoretical roots: social comparison, workplace envy, relative deprivation, and self-esteem, plus the three factors from the 2025 Bandung study.

Menyusun respons tiga level yang bisa langsung dieksekusi: individu, tim & kepemimpinan, dan organisasi.Assembled a three-level response ready to execute: individual, team & leadership, and organization.

Ember hanya berkuasa selama kepiting saling menarik ke bawah. Budaya kerja yang sehat dimulai dari orang pertama yang berhenti menarik. The bucket only rules while the crabs keep pulling each other down. A healthy culture starts with the first person who stops pulling.

10 / 11

Daftar PustakaReferences

Referensi (APA 7)References (APA 7)

Duffy, M. K., Lee, K., & Adair, E. A. (2021). Workplace envy. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 8, 19–44. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-012420-055746

Miller, C. D. (2019). Exploring the crabs in the barrel syndrome in organizations. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 26(3), 352–371. https://doi.org/10.1177/1548051819849009

Purwaningwulan, M. M., & Khaira, G. (2025). The phenomenon of crab mentality among employees in Bandung City in self-development process. Jurnal Komunikasi Ikatan Sarjana Komunikasi Indonesia, 10(1), 50–61. https://doi.org/10.25008/jkiski.v10i1.1187

Uzum, B., Ozdemir, Y., Kose, S., Ozkan, O. S., & Seneldir, O. (2022). Crab barrel syndrome: Looking through the lens of type A and type B personality theory and social comparison process. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, Article 792137. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.792137

Catatan verifikasi: entri Frontiers in Psychology (2022) telah dikoreksi ke penulis terverifikasi (Uzum et al.), menggantikan atribusi sebelumnya yang keliru. Verification note: the Frontiers in Psychology (2022) entry has been corrected to the verified authors (Uzum et al.), replacing an earlier misattribution.

11 / 11